Recently, there has been a concerning development regarding the use of AI Overviews by Google that has raised questions about the future of journalism. A writer for WIRED discovered that the AI Overview feature used a significant portion of their article in a search result, without properly attributing the content.
Uncredited Content
The writer was startled to find that the first paragraph of the AI Overview response directly mirrored their writing, with minimal changes in phrasing. This lack of proper attribution raises concerns about the originality and integrity of content when it is reproduced by AI technologies.
Despite Google’s assertion that the AI Overviews are meant to direct users back to the original sources, the placement of the source links at the bottom of the result box makes it unlikely for users to click through to the original article. This raises questions about the impact on traffic and visibility for publishers whose content is utilized in AI Overviews.
Impact on Click-Through Rates
One claim made by Google was that links included in AI Overviews receive more clicks compared to traditional web listings. However, no data was provided to support this assertion, leaving doubt about the actual impact on click-through rates. Additionally, comparing AI Overview referral traffic to blue-link traffic from Google may not provide a comprehensive picture of the effect on articles chosen for featured snippets.
In terms of copyright infringement, legal experts are skeptical about the success of any potential litigation against AI Overviews. Copyright law tends to prioritize useful and helpful content, making it challenging to make a strong case for infringement in the case of fact-based writing such as instructional columns.
While AI technologies like Overviews may offer efficiency and convenience in accessing information, the ethical implications of using content without proper attribution and potentially impacting the visibility and traffic of original sources cannot be ignored. There needs to be a balance between technological advancement and respecting the intellectual property rights of creators.
The use of AI Overviews raises significant concerns about the future of journalism and content creation. While technology continues to evolve and provide new ways to access information, it is essential to consider the ethical and legal implications of using AI to replicate and distribute content. Transparency, attribution, and respect for intellectual property are crucial in navigating the intersection of AI and journalism.
Leave a Reply